Javier Milei will be a good case study on why trying to fix the problems caused by socialism ends up creating more socialists. Canada will end up same

CaptainTrouble

Based Member
Argentina was basically a country that was close to maxing out its credit card after going on a spending spree. Milei got into power and actually made a sustainable budget to reign in the excessive spending that would have led to a catastrophic result if Argentina continued the way it was going.

To put things into perspective: before Milei took power in 2023 the debt-to-gdp was 155%. Since he's been in power, it has shrunk to 78.4% in 2025 and is expected to shrink to 69% this year. GNI Per Capita (PPP Adjusted) was $29,600 in 2023 and $31,920 in 2025 with it expected to rise again. So, things are improving there.

The issue is that to make thing improve in Argentina, Milei needed to cut wasteful government spending. The problem is that many people's jobs only existed because of wasteful government spending. Unemployment went from 6.14% to 7.40% over the last two years.

Milei's approval is only 35%. Milei essentially saved the country from a major financial catastrophe (it had double digit inflation which he curbed and there was a debt crisis looming) but the people are not happy because many who were working worthless jobs, ended up losing their worthless jobs. All these people are rallying everyone about how terrible Milei's policies are when in reality, he's doing good for the country.


There's a lesson here for Canada. Socialism is self-enforcing. When you try to correct for it, you end up getting more socialists and we have seen similar things before whenever conservatives get in. I predict this situation is going to happen in Canada soon enough. My calculations suggest Canada is going to be having its own debt crisis by about 2040-2050. Another decade reign by Carney and we could be forced into an "austerity" situation and then Canadians will be back on the socialist train.

There is an interesting footnote. Milei is extremely pro-Israel (but can any politician survive if they aren't, especially in the Americas) and some have accused him of trying to gut his country and sell everything cheap but in reality his changes have actually improved the value of capital so everything costs more if jews were going to buy things, so this criticism doesn't really hold. The big issue is he signed contracts with Israel for all of the countries major water treatment facilities. To let the people who poisoned wells with the black plague control of your water seems like a bad idea (and it will be) so he's not all good but outside of the pro-jew stuff, it's interesting to watch all the liberals bitch and complain about a guy who has been fixing the country.
 
Upvote 4
I often wonder if socialism is simply a phase a people must experience. It isn't the sort of thing that can be educated against or policied against. Once a population starts to flirt with it they will not stop until sufficient deaths by famine have occured to correct that impulse naturally.

In the same way socialism is self enforcing it also ends up self sabotaging. What I mean by that is I have never met a leftist who didn't think the solution was further left.

You see this repeatedly in the Soviet Union trying to apply Marxist theory to places it does not belong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism

You see this here with social workers wanting more safe supply and more decriminalization despite the obvious failures they must double down on "progressive policies"

The political left is comprised of people who do not care that you have solved any problems they care how you did it and how the solution made them feel. Milei not unlike Bukele in El Salvador has tried fixing some problems and had some success.

They didn't do it under any banner of leftism so they are the enemy to the left.

Mostly they don't want problems solved they want to feel power vicariously through politics. Someone not on their team having even some success is a major threat to that collective ego.
 
Argentine opinion polls are just as full of shit as everywhere else, maybe more so because of just how deeply entrenched the Peronist machine is in all of their institutions and civil society. The polls were predicting a clear defeat for Milei's party in their midterm elections last year, but the opposite ended up happening: they actually gained seats.

Safe to say his "approval rating" is probably also not reflective of reality.
 
The modern world was built by people who had more ability, drive, and strength than most of the people living today. The socialist message resonates with people like that. "Don't worry, daddy government will handle it. No need for personal responsibility"

There's a place where everyone is housed, clothed and fed. Sounds like paradise if you explain it 'the right way'. The truth is they are always describing prison, because that's what prison is. Prison is actually superior to the reality of socialism, especially once you discover how many people starved to death.
 
Back
Top