Fine: Dogs or Muslims?

border_humper

Staff Member
Moderator
Chief Disinfo Officer

Democrats are scrambling to condemn Florida Rep. Randy Fine for his unapologetic defense of American pet ownership against radical Islamic demands to ban dogs as “unclean.”
The firestorm erupted after New York Muslim activist Nerdeen Kiswani declared, “Dogs definitely have a place in society, just not as indoor pets. Like we [Muslims have] said all along, they are unclean [“najis”].”
Kiswani later claimed, “Lmao at the Zionists frothing at the mouth at this, thinking they’re doing something. It’s obviously a joke I don’t care if you have a dog, I do care if your dog is shitting everywhere and you’re not cleaning it.”

In response, Fine laid out the stark choice: “If they force us to choose, the choice between dogs and Muslims is not a difficult one.”
For context, this is the leader of one of the key mainstream Muslim groups that supported Mamdani. pic.twitter.com/zcIs4tVyly
— Congressman Randy Fine (@RepFine) February 15, 2026
pic.twitter.com/GVWZFm6D86
— Congressman Randy Fine (@RepFine) February 16, 2026
Democrats piled on Fine, with Rep. Ro Khanna calling it “Disgusting bigotry” and demanding, “Fine must be censured.”

Khanna doubled down: “Taking an alleged comment by one person and attributing it to everyone who shares that person’s faith is the definition of bigotry.”
Rep. Dan Goldman labeled it an “Islamophobic” comment that’s “incredibly damaging to Jews trying to combat antisemitism.”

Rep. Eric Swalwell insisted, “America is BETTER because of our Muslim community” and “we are WORSE when assholes like this guy spout hate.”

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez fumed, “This is genuinely one of the most disgusting statements I have ever seen issued by an American official,” adding, “Fine should be censured & stripped of committees.”

Fine’s opponent Jennifer Jenkins vowed, “I’m running to kick that bigot out of Washington.”

Rep. Bob Menendez complained, “This is what it looks like when Islamophobia and outrage are the only two items on your political agenda.”

California Gov. Gavin Newsom barked, “Resign now, you racist slob.”

Leftist media figures like CNN’s Jake Tapper echoed, “Disgusting bigotry,” while New York Times’ David French called it “Absolutely evil.”
I’ve often considered the question myself.
 
Upvote 8



I’ve often considered the question myself.
border_humper
From the Hadith, which all good muslims must obey (much of islam comes from it),

Abu Talhah reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The angels do not enter a house in which there is a dog, nor an image in a likeness.” Abu Talhah said, “The Prophet means by likeness an image of living souls.”

Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3225, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2106

So this is exactly what muslims believe, and given the choice between muslims and dogs I will take dogs every time.
 
I will take dogs over Muslims any day. If they do not like dogs the GTFO and go back or to any of the Muslim countries. Like why are they here if all they ever do is bitch about our lifestyle etc?

Interesting though they consider cats clean and are highly regarded but I do not think as mush as ancient Egyptians though.

Plus we all know how they view goats......
 
The reason almost anyone doesn't like dogs (including Muslims) is because they're from an area with significant wild dog populations. This will lead to a culture in which people learn to dislike dogs. Why do many countries with significant populations of wild dogs tend to be Muslims rather than White? Because White people have always had much better control over their societies such that White societies cleaned up the wild dogs a couple hundred years ago. Dogs were never commonly regarded as pets even for White people until a century ago.
 
View previous replies…
My main issue with dogs is their owners who let their dogs shit anywhere and do not clean it up.

Your are correct about dogs in the west they are relatively new to being domesticated whereas say cats have been domesticated for millenniums..
 
@ayn_rands_ghost Fortunately, I've never ran into an issue with dogs in public but I think we're walking a fine line. If all of a sudden the Jeets and Muslims decided they wanted to emulate Canadians by getting dogs... yeah... no thanks. That'll be a disaster. We're lucky these people don't like dogs.

I just hate how dogs impact human-to-human socializing so much. Every person I know with a dog aligns their daily routine around their dog. Can't do X, have to pickup dog from daycare. Can't do Y because I have to go home and once the dog sees me, he'll get separation anxiety and start barking then the neighbors will complain so... and the list goes on forever. Then you go over to someone's house and you've got hair on everything. Bought a new bag and brought it over to your friend's place? Dog chewed on it ofc. Oh, that's a scratch on my new dress shoes for work, great. Then, if the dog isn't sleeping he's trying to be center of attention. I don't hate dogs, I just find them annoying and especially because of the circumstances the owners choose to live in with their dogs. I've been to enough single bedroom apartments with bullmastiff sized dogs, with hair and slobber everywhere to just roll my eyes. Usually it's some 100 pound girl and the dog is bigger than her. That's also a joke... whenever I see girls walking their dog, I can't help but think the dog is walking her. And pit bulls? Don't even get me started on them. I've never met someone who wasn't trash who owned one. They're the ghetto dog.
 
@CaptainTrouble I do not hate dogs either but I see what you mean with friends and relatives that own dogs as their lives are literally revolved around them. Plus it makes it harder to go away for a night or two. That is why I have indoor cats for pets..

I always thought it was strange people had big dogs or really any dog in apartments. Like what do they do with dog all day? I know some use kennels/cages to put them into but even if you work 8 hours it is probably closer to 10 between when you leave and get home and I can not see a dog holding it that long either.

I have seen that lots too where the dog walks the owner....
 
@ayn_rands_ghost as an experienced dating (likes hot women) aficionado... my experience says it's a boyfriend replacement. Hardly anyone talks about it though, probably because the admission is somewhat shameful and difficult. A lot of people are missing that "void" of warmth from the human touch. Both men and women often get dogs as a means to emulate what they lack from the opposite sex. I believe this is especially true when small women get big dogs. The big dog is almost emulating that big strong man protector feeling she desires, whereas women that get much smaller dogs are more likely filling the nurturing void of a lack of child than necessarily a BF replacement.

What do they do all day? Usually, cuddle with the dog. What's more concerning to me is whether they shut the door when they're masturbating with their dragon dildos or if the dog is watching that... cause when I go over to small women's places that have big dogs and we get into bed, then the dog jumps up and already has his penis out (has happened multiple times before), I do start to question just how far they're going in replacing that BF. (The dog pill is real).

It's also why I wasn't joking when I said I prefer women without dogs. The fact they've already succumbed to the pressure of owning a dog instead of seeking out a good relationship with a man makes me feel like they're already given up and are using the dog as a crux so to not put as much effort into chasing men as they ought to be given the void they feel.
 
Back
Top